Is a metal roof cheaper than shingles? No, it is initially more expensive. But it gives more value in the long run. The cost of installing a new shingle roof is between $6,000 and $9,800. A metal roof is approximately $15,000 to $24,500.
The actual question is which roof is more long-term worthy. To get the complete picture, you must consider the length of each roof, the amount of maintenance it will need, the amount of energy it will save, and the amount you will earn back.
Understanding the Initial Cost Gap
The initial difference in prices is high. The price of asphalt shingles is approximately $4 to $8 per square foot, installed. The cost of metal roofing ranges between $4 to $30 per square foot, depending on the type. The most popular premium, standing-seam metal roofing, costs between $12 and $16 per square foot.
By Type of Material:
- 3-tab asphalt shingles: 4 to 6 dollars per square foot.
- Architectural shingles: 5 to 8 dollars per square foot.
- High-end asphalt shingles: 8 to 13 dollars per square foot.
- Corrugated metal panels: 4 to 7 dollars per square foot.
- Standing-seam metal: 10 to 16 dollars per square foot.
- High-quality metals (copper, zinc): 15 to 30 dollars per square foot.
The cost of labor may vary widely. A metal roof will typically cost between $300 and $500 per square (100 square feet) as opposed to approximately $200 to $300 per square of asphalt shingles. The increased cost of labor is because of the additional skill required to install a metal roof.
The Lifespan Factor Changes Everything
When thinking about “is a metal roof cheaper than shingles,” over time, lifespan becomes the game-changer. Asphalt shingles last 15 to 30 years, while metal roofs can last 40 to 100 years depending on the material.
Real-life scenario: A homeowner spends $8,000 to install architectural shingles and replaces them twice in 50 years, totaling $24,000. In the meantime, the metal roof that costs $20,000 covers the entire 50-year duration, which saves $4,000.
Maintenance expenses are no different. Asphalt shingles require repair after every 10-15 years, and it costs around $500-$1000 to repair. Maintenance of metal roofs is minimal, and repairs are seldom required, and when they are, they are more expensive.
Energy Savings Create Hidden Value
Metal roofs can save you a lot of energy compared to what asphalt shingles can. Reflective metal roofs can reduce cooling expenses by 10-40 percent. A 1,770 square foot home saves a homeowner up to $128 a year.
Comparisons of energy performance:
- Metal roofs: Reflect sunlight in the attic, lowering attic temperatures and cooling expenses.
- Asphalt shingles: They absorb heat, which raises air conditioning consumption and energy costs.
- Yearly savings: 50 to 200 dollars per year on average-sized houses.
- Lifetime savings: 2,500 to 10,000 dollars in 50 years.
These savings accumulate, and metal roofs are more economical than heat-absorbing shingles.
Professional Installation Matters
Quality roof replacements are important. They influence the life span of your materials and the performance of the system. Metal roofing is a skilled work and needs proper flashing and fastener positioning.
An unqualified contractor may invalidate a warranty and lead to costly errors. Installation of asphalt shingles is easier, though even in this case, proper methods are required to achieve the maximum life. When the work is poorly done, a 30-year shingle can wear out in 15 years, eliminating its cost advantage.
Return on Investment Analysis
Depending on the material you select, there will be a difference in home value. The latest research indicates that you can get 60% to 70% returns on your investment when you replace asphalt shingles, and metal roofs will provide you with 48.9% returns. In some markets, metal roofs increase home prices more.
Take into consideration the following:
- Asphalt shingles have a greater immediate ROI but have to be replaced earlier.
- Metal roofs have a less immediate payoff but contribute permanent value and appeal.
- Value is affected by market factors including climate, local preferences, and home style.
- Metal roofs can be worth it in case you intend to live in your home 15 years or longer.
Making the Right Choice for Your Home
Deciding whether a metal roof is cheaper than shingles depends on your specific situation. Think about these factors when comparing roofing materials pros and cons:
Select asphalt shingles if:
- Budget constraints: Want the lowest initial cost.
- Short-term ownership: Expect to sell within 10 years.
- Mild climate: Temperate weather.
- Classic style: Home design fits the classic shingle look.
Select metal roofing if:
- Long-term investment: 20+ years.
- Energy savings priority: Want to save on cooling.
- Durability emphasis: Want maximum weather proofing.
- Low maintenance: Want a low maintenance lifestyle.
For homeowners wondering can you put a metal roof over shingles, this option can sometimes reduce installation costs while providing metal’s benefits.
Your Next Step with Professional Roof Replacement Services
Metal roof is more expensive initially but is usually less expensive in the long run. It is longer-lasting, energy-saving, and requires less maintenance. In order to save money, locate a professional who has worked on both types of roofing and will provide you with clear cost estimates.
Do not make decisions based on initial costs. Consider the needs of your house, the climate in the area, and your future plans. Professional roof replacement services will assist you in calculating the overall cost of ownership and make the economically wise decision.
For detailed cost analysis specific to your area, check out our roof replacement cost guide for 3,000 sq ft houses. Understanding how often a roof needs to be replaced can also help you plan your investment better.
Are you ready to explore? Call DLV Roofing now to get a full assessment and free quote that takes into account all the factors that influence the actual cost and value of your roof. We are a professional team that serves various locations and can assist you in making the most appropriate choice of your home and budget.
